PHILADELPHIA HOME RULE CHARTER
CHAPTER 2 REMOVAL OF APPOINTIVE OFFICERS
§9-201. Managing Director.
The Managing Director may be removed by the Mayor. If the
Mayor removes the Managing Director, he shall specify in writing and in detail
his reasons for doing so and shall cause this specification to be served upon
the Managing Director. The Managing Director may, within ten days after receipt
of such specification, file with the Civil Service Commission a request for a
public hearing before it, and thereupon the Civil Service Commission shall
promptly afford him such a hearing. If the Civil Service Commission finds the
Mayor's charges well founded and a sufficient cause for dismissal, that
shall be the end of the matter, but if the Commission shall find that the
charges were not well founded or that they do not constitute a sufficient cause
for dismissal, the Commission may award to the Managing Director his salary for
the balance of his term or such part thereof as it deems appropriate, and the
Council shall promptly make an appropriation out of which the award can be
paid.
ANNOTATION
Sources: No specific source.
Purposes: The office of Managing Director is one of the most
important new offices created by this Charter. See Article V, Chapter 1. The
nature of the duties to be performed by this officer are such as to make
desirable his having some measure of independence and freedom from unwarranted
pressures from the Mayor himself. Yet so fundamental is the necessity for
maintaining in the Mayor the power to remove that such power must be preserved
even as to this office. See Annotation to Section 9-200. One more consideration
enters: it is that of being able to attract to the office of Managing Director
an individual of experience and ability. This section seeks to balance these
conflicting considerations. The power of the Mayor to discharge is preserved but
he does so at the risk of the Civil Service Commission finding his action
unfounded and without sufficient cause, a factor that might well be grounds for
a recall proceeding. Nevertheless, to assure administrative harmony the
dismissal stands but the Managing Director may be awarded all or part of his
salary for the balance of his term. The latter is intended to afford a measure
of security, financially, to an experienced and able governmental or business
official requested to assume the office of Managing Director and to leave his
then position and employment. If the Civil Service Commission finds the
Mayor's action well founded and sufficient cause for dismissal, no reason
exists for awarding any salary for the balance of the term or any part of it.
See generally Annotation to Section 3-403.